Bitcoin: Sound money or bubble?

Hybrid-Content-Crypto-currencySo, Bitcoin’s in the news again. This time for having fallen more than 60% off its all-time high that it hit just last December. Call me a pessimist but this seems to look less like volatility and more like reality. For all of you who haven’t really read up on Bitcoin, its the most popular of many ‘Crypto currencies.’ Let’s get into some basics first.

Why a Crypto Currency?

Over 5000 years that mankind has known the concepts of money and currency they have been regulated by governments for most of that period. This leads to unlimited potential for government level intervention which adds to the cost of transacting. This is exactly why using a Credit Card entails the merchant losing part of his profit to ‘charges.’ Or, an international remittance attracting transaction fees across currencies and exchanges.

Satoshi Nakomoto, an anonymous developer put out Bitcoin in 2009. Not only did this person roll out the first Crypto Currency, he also made the code open-source, free for all. The Crypto Currency concept seems to have eliminated the inter banking and inter country (cross currency) transaction fee problem by levying very small transaction fees and has deregulated currency altogether with no government control whatsoever.

Is it a bubble? Is it a pyramid scheme? 

Lets be fair and frank here. It does not look like a pyramid scheme or a bunch of men in jackets and ties to drive the price of Bitcoin up in an attempt to get out at the top. In fact, almost all Bitcoin protagonists I have followed on the internet state in their interviews, that Bitcoin is more a way of life for them, than a temporary safe haven for their currency.

Here’s where the problem starts. Over the last year or two, people seem to have pumped a lot of money into this crypto currency without knowing the underlying facts.

What is money? 

Now this next paragraph is a crash course on 5000 years of money.

Money is an article or an object that is used as a viable tool of exchange against purchase of products or services. Mankind has known the concept of money for over 5000 years right since the time we traded cows for wheat or goats for wood. Somewhere down the line, we realised that barter is actioned much more efficiently by using standardised pieces of exchange. Hence was born the concept of gold and silver nuggets, coins and rounds. Then came a time when carrying around gold and silver wasn’t considered viable which lead to the physical gold being stored and vaults and the owners of said gold being handed over slips of paper as a claim check for the stored gold. This carried on right up till 1971 when President Nixon of the USA pulled our monetary system off the gold standard. Now I can go on a tangent here and begin to explain how, since 1971 our currency is nothing but pieces of paper with no value whatsoever, but that’s better explained in a whole new article.

The reason for explaining the evolution of money was to bring out the key properties money needs to possess. It needs to be:

  • A standard medium of exchange – Easily recognisable as a piece of value
  • Durable – Not wither away with time or get destroyed easily
  • Fungible – A buck in your pocket is  the same as a buck in my pocket
  • Portable – Not as big as a cow or a goat. Should fit in your pocket or on your person.
  • A store of value! – This is the most important property money must possess which currencies today DO NOT.

Is Bitcoin Money? 

Now this is where most people, including myself, disagree. They say Gold and Silver are truly money. They are both a medium of exchange, they are durable when minted into coins and rounds, they are also portable. Gold and Silver have gained in purchasing power, as history has it, because of their limited availability on our earth. Hence, they are most certainly a store of value.

BitCoin features most of the required properties! But, is it a store of value? Analysts and BitCoin protagonists say it is a store of value because of its limited nature. There are only ever going to be 21 million BitCoins mined. Hence one day we will reach a stage where all 21 million BitCoins in various sizes and denominations will be in the hands of the world population. But, what about the advent of other crypto currencies? Its as simple as a few mouse clicks to start your own crypto currency and call it Hybrid Coin or XYZ Coin. Hence who’s to say a more fancy sounding coin takes over with a bunch of new features rendering BitCoin worthless?

BitCoin can be duplicated time and time again unlike Gold, Silver, Platinum and Palladium which are precious metals, true money, limited and cannot be duplicated.


I do not think BitCoin is sound money, and this is just MY opinion. I think its a great idea, a noble idea and whoever though about it had his heart in the right place. However, historically, money has always needed to be a store of value, which is a place where BitCoin fails miserably. BitCoin went from over a 1000 dollars last month to just over 450 dollars as of now. It highly sentiment driven and the volatility just doesn’t seem to be getting better with time.





Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: